In my youth, with a few rare exceptions, there was a clear demarcation between science fiction and the muggle world of the literary establishment. The difference was startling:
The science fiction stories were constructed according to sound and true principles of story telling. Establishment works were pretentious. artsy, experimental, elliptical, unreadable.
The science fiction story held recognizable characters, often larger than life, doing recognizable things. The establishment stories were about smaller than life characters, dipsomaniacs and coprophagics, doing meaningless actions in a meaningless universe.
Science fiction stories were oriented toward the future, to far horizons, to great adventures, and were set in worlds were no man has gone before. Establishment stories were set in back yard or some foul place, a waste dump, concentration camp or abattoir, requiring no imagination to describe or envision.
Science fiction stories were about something. Establishment stories were about nothing.
The science fiction stories were imaginative, the readership was imaginative, and no idea was too dangerous to contemplate. Science fiction readers were bold.
Establishment stories were parochial, never looked outside their narrow range of approved, conformist, herd-animal views, regarded all challenges to those views not merely as uncouth and unreasonable, but as heresy.
Their ideas were so fragile that the contrary opinion could not even be discussed.Establishment muggles were cowards.
My whole life, I dreamed of being a science fiction writer. I wanted to be in the same circles as the imaginative and bold, where the trembling, mole-eyed muggles dared not go.
Of all the things I could have foreseen in my youth, the last was what did happen:
I joined SFWA just as it was dying, and was nominated for Nebula, and then Hugo Awards, just as these awards died. In all three cases, the once-great institution died of the same cause. Each contracted the Thought Police disease, which is always fatal to the mind.
And, lo and behold, now the science fiction world conform to all the Establishment canons.
Read the remainder of this entry »