Archive for May, 2012

The Role of Incoherence

The sum and substance of all this foregoing is that, for the Moderns, evil is good and good is evil. Virtue is vice. Ugliness is Beauty. Lies are Truth. Men are beasts and beasts are men; men are women; adults are children; chastity is indecent and indecency is decent. Everything is nothing and Nothing is all that there is. A is non-A.

The error here is fundamentally philosophical: the Modern Age is the first age in history with no metaphysical beliefs, aside, perhaps, from a self-contradictory and crude form of materialism.

Without a metaphysics, nothing else in philosophy coheres.

Read the remainder of this entry »

1 Comment. Join the Conversation

Seven Deadly Sins

And what happens when each passion is left to advocate its own justification?

Read the remainder of this entry »

9 Comments so far. Join the Conversation

Avengers Assemble!

Posted May 6, 2012 By John C Wright

The new Avengers movie is extremely well done. Each character has his moment to shine, and the soap opera and the action are all in the fine old Marvel manner. Worth seeing in a theater.

Also, to my surprise, there was no liberal ‘sucker punch’ hidden anywhere in the film, no flourish of liberal credentials. There are even one or two lines uttered by Captain America so wholesome and reverent that I was pleasantly surprised, even proud, that the director Joss Whedan put storyline above partisanship.

It is a movie conservatives can love.

13 Comments so far. Join the Conversation

Another Triumph for the Darkness — Chen Betrayed

Posted May 3, 2012 By John C Wright

From All Girls Allowed. I am particularly outraged by the failure of our government to lift a finger to help. One of the few things President Clinton did that I admired was save another famous Chinese activist.

Here is the announcement from All Girls Allowed, a group attempting to stem the tide of both prenatal and postnatal infanticides pandemic in China, aggravated by their nightmarish One (usually one boy) Child Policy.

At the end of last week, exciting news broke out of the escape of Chen Guangcheng, the blind attorney who was imprisoned in 2006 for filing a class action suit against the Chinese government on behalf of 130,000+ victims of forced sterilization.  The western media immediately picked up the story, as Chen’s escape was daring and occurred at a critical time ahead of Secretary of State Hillary Clinton’s visit to Beijing.

Unfortunately, recent reports have revealed that the U.S. government has reneged on its promises to help Chen and his family to safety, as Chen was sent out of the U.S. embassy to a hospital with no embassy escorts.  He is now pleading for the opportunity for his family to safely leave China.

In a statement, Chai Ling said, “It’s disappointing. Chen’s escape gave the U.S. a chance to demonstrate its commitment to freedom and be on the right side of history-and now the chance is all but gone.” Chen’s friends have said that he is already under intense government surveillance and has not been allowed to make outside contact. Ling continued: “Secretary Clinton, whose work I’ve admired, had the power to provide asylum for Chen and his family. But she gave way under pressure-and now we don’t even know what will become of the activists who were arrested last week after helping Chen escape.” 

While the mainstream media has been quick to point to Chen’s daring escape, there has been very little mention of the cause for which he has suffered–the defense of millions of women who have suffered forced abortion and forced sterilization under China’s brutal One-Child Policy.

Read Ling’s Huffington Post article here.

And an article from the Atlantic  here, which reads in part:

A little over 12 hours after blind Chinese activist Chen Guangcheng was released from the U.S. embassy in Beijing, to which he had fled after escaping house arrest, Chen now says that American officials encouraged him to leave the safe haven of the embassy building, in part by making promises that they failed to keep. In an interview with CNN’s Steven Jiang, he expressed deep disappointment with the U.S. and with President Barack Obama personally. He said that embassy officials were no longer picking up his calls and that he already felt his rights being “violated” by the Chinese government, which had promised him his freedom in exchange for him leaving the embassy. He strenuously and repeatedly asked the U.S. and Obama to help him and his family leave China.

The interview portrays Chen as furious at the U.S., which he had only 24 hours ago seen as his greatest hope, and portrays the Obama administration as having sold out the high-profile activist, who in 2005 made an enemy of the Chinese government when he campaigned against thousands of forced abortions and forced sterilizations.

The interview, initially published on Jiang’s verified blogspot account, has since been removed. Neither he nor CNN appear to have explained why. (Update: Jiang, on Twitter, says he removed the interview to re-post it later as part of a larger CNN.com story, which is now up.)

Chen’s comments portray the U.S. as manipulating him, cutting him off from outside communication and encouraging him to leave the embassy rather than seek asylum. He said he was denied his requests to call friends. He said he felt the embassy officials had lied to him.

 

12 Comments so far. Join the Conversation

What’s Wrong With The World Part XIX—Confused

Posted May 2, 2012 By John C Wright

Confused

The main thing dismissed by modern writers as being, since not open to empirical confirmation, ergo either mere opinion or mere myth, is that reality which forms the basis of ethical, political and aesthetic philosophy: the idea moderns forget is the idea that there is something that the mind of man can grasp which is not invented arbitrarily by the mind of man, including norms and imperatives of thought, passion, and feeling. That reality is called Natural Law or Right Reason.

It was not until quite late in my life—after I was married, in fact—that I realized how thoroughly and entirely the Modern Age had repudiated the idea of Natural Law and Right Reason. Two anecdotes spring to mind.

Read the remainder of this entry »

76 Comments so far. Join the Conversation
The Role of Science

Oddly enough, this is the only aspect of the rot of the modern world which I think could be solved by a diligent application of philosophical learning. If students and scientists were trained, not only in science, but in the philosophical and metaphysical underpinnings logically necessary for science, and if scientists publically and frequently repeated the rule and hence the limitations of the scientific method, then those things which claim to be science but which are patently absurd unscience and antiscience, such as socialism, materialism, eugenics, social engineering, would be etiolated of their usurpative and abusive claim to be science or scientific.

Read the remainder of this entry »

17 Comments so far. Join the Conversation

What’s Wrong With The World Part XVII—Foolish

Posted May 1, 2012 By John C Wright

Foolish

The one aspect of philosophy which stands as a shining exception to the criminal neglect of philosophy of the modern age is the study of the natural world, the discipline called natural philosophy or physics.

Here, it is not the ignorance or neglect of philosophy which is the error; the error is the over-emphasis, the exaggeration, the idolatry of science which leads to a perversion and hence, ultimately, to a neglect of science.

A basic and repeated folly of Modernism springs from a single cause: with the well-merited success and progress brought about by the scientific and industrial revolution in the West, the intelligentsia of three and four generations sought to idolize the physical sciences, and apply empirical methods to the study of Man.

Read the remainder of this entry »

57 Comments so far. Join the Conversation

What’s Wrong With The World Part XVI —Ugly

Posted May 1, 2012 By John C Wright

Ugly

I had always, even from earliest youth, known that something had gone terribly wrong with the world at about the time of the industrial revolution. Up until about the time of the Victorians, and lingering in every dwindling spots and spasms up until the Great War, music still displayed harmony and melody, poetry still spoke like music, painting looked like what they represented, novels contained matter to delight the senses, inspire the soul, and educate the mind.

Then something happened; Something horrible.

If a primordial monstrosity from a novel by H.P. Lovecraft had risen from the deep and driven all mankind instantly into screaming paroxysms of insanity, the magnitude of what happened could not have been greater.

Something horrible happened. Beauty died.

The first thing a traveler brought forth from the past would notice, if escorted by the Ghost of Christmas Past or the time machine of H.G. Wells into a modern industrial center or modern museum of the fine arts, is the overwhelming ugliness of the age.

Read the remainder of this entry »

35 Comments so far. Join the Conversation